Destruction (Spoliation) of Evidence in Trucking Cases

Truck Accident Lawyer Advocating for Knoxville Residents and Other East Tennessee Victims

Like other businesses, trucking companies must maintain business records and various data required by law. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) requires trucking companies to collect and maintain certain data about their drivers and trucks. Unfortunately, some trucking companies fail to collect the appropriate data or even destroy records once they realize that there is a possibility of litigation based on a truck accident in East Tennessee. You should make sure to discuss your case with Knoxville truck accident attorney Mark Hartsoe, who can make sure that vital data is preserved and hold defendants accountable for the spoliation of evidence when appropriate.

Understanding Spoliation of Evidence in Trucking Cases

The destruction of evidence is also called spoliation of evidence. It is defined as significantly altering or destroying property or failing to preserve property that might be used as evidence in reasonably foreseeable litigation. When a trucking company learns that one of its drivers got into an accident, it may engage in spoliation of evidence in order to conceal its negligence or the negligence of its driver. This spoliation may happen very soon after an accident, which may present a significant problem for an injured plaintiff.

In Tennessee, a defendant's spoliation of evidence allows a court to draw a negative inference against a defendant that improperly destroyed or altered evidence. It may also be a basis for sanctions being imposed by the court. A trial court has the discretion to sanction the defendant if its spoliation of evidence occurs in circumstances that show fraud or a desire to suppress what happened, and the spoliation causes severe prejudice to the other party.

You should retain injury attorney Mark Hartsoe right away after being involved in a truck accident. If you retain our firm, we will notify the truck driver and the trucking company of your claim right away, putting them on notice that they should not destroy any evidence and that they have a duty to preserve any evidence relevant to the accident.

Usually, in a truck accident case, you will need to establish the negligence of the defendant driver or trucking company. In other words, you would need to show that the driver failed to drive safely and that this failure caused the accident that resulted in your injuries and damages. A trucking company may be held indirectly liable by using a theory of vicarious liability. This means that if the driver was negligent in the course and scope of employment, while on duty and working for the trucking company, the trucking company may be held accountable for the damages as well.

Discuss Your Truck Accident Claim with Knoxville Attorney Mark Hartsoe

At the Hartsoe Law Firm, we are ready to pursue compensation on your behalf if you were hurt by the negligence of a truck driver or trucking company. If you believe that a truck driver was at fault in causing your crash and are concerned about the destruction of evidence, you should consult Knoxville truck accident lawyer Mark Hartsoe, who has significant experience in these cases. Call the Hartsoe Law Firm at (865) 524-5657 or contact us via our online form to set up a free appointment. Hartsoe advocates for victims who need a motor vehicle collision attorney in many areas of East Tennessee, including Knox, Blount, Anderson, Campbell, Claiborne, Cocke, Cumberland, Fentress, Grainger, Greene, Hamblen, Hamilton, and Jefferson Counties.

Client Reviews
I was on my way to Atlanta and a huge truck rear-ended me and knocked me off the side of the road. I was scared. Didn’t know what to do. I tried working with the insurance company. They are just difficult to work with. I had to call somebody to take care of me. So, My brother told me to call Mark Hartsoe. As soon as I called Mark Hartsoe, he let me know real quick that everything was going to be okay and that he would take care of everything. And, he did. He got me a great settlement. He took the worry off of me.
★★★★★
I was hit coming home late at night by a drunk driver who took off. And the next day I was able to track down his vehicle and get the state police involved. At that point, a family friend recommended that I talk to Mark Hartsoe. Pretty much at that point, Mark handled the police, the insurance company and the guy who hit me. Settled with the actual person that hit me. Outside of that, everything came out great. Did not have to go to court. Got a great settlement. Got my car replaced. Got a check. Mark Hartsoe is my lawyer. Nate Holder
★★★★★
I was involved in a motorcycle accident. It was a head-on collision. I broke my arm, injured by knee. I was out of work for a long time and had medical bills, other expenses. A personal friend handed me a card for Mark Hartsoe. I called Mark Hartsoe from the side of the road and he took care of everything. My case was settled out of court. I received a great settlement. Bike was totaled, motorcycle was replaced. It was easy, painless. About as painless as something like this can be. This is why my lawyer is Mark Hartsoe. John Lusinger
★★★★★
I wanted to thank you for the excellent representation and your ability to handle the situation so well with such compassion and strength. We appreciate all of your help, concern and for answering my many questions. It has been a difficult road to travel but when we come across people like you, it really helps to lighten the load. We just wanted you to know how much we appreciate what you’ve done and your ability to handle the situation so well. S. Carter
★★★★★
Thank you so much for all the work you did on our case. We received more than we expected. You were great through the whole time from the first meeting until the last. Thank you so very much. Sam & Judy Kachar
★★★★★
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
Super Lawyers
Fellow Litigation Counsel of America
National Association of Distinguished Counsel
Avvo Rating
Cityview Top Lawyers
Martindale Hubbell AV Rated
Hartsoe Bros. Farm